top of page
Search

The Monophonic Dialogue of Echoes

1 day ago
6 min read

In Gerard Manley Hopkins’ “The Leaden Echo and the Golden Echo,” there seems to be a dialogue of two voices: the Leaden Echo complains about the transience of beauty, yet the Golden Echo instills hope by emphasizing that the beauty dedicated to God will not pass away.[1] However, could this “dialogue” be presenting doubt as opposed to God’s eternity, and could the Golden Echo also be an echo of Leaden Echo's voice? Mikhail Bakhtin asserted the conceptions of “dialogue” and “polyphony” for the novel genre;[2] yet, those notions can also be taken into consideration in terms of the dialogic structure of this poem. In the poem, the voices of the echoes that dialogue with each other do not seem “dialogic” despite their dialogue; there seems to be a single voice rather than polyphony. Even though two different echoes are speaking, the sudden breaks and the distressed repetitions in the restless syntax show that the discourse has not wholly changed. The restlessness arising from the transience of beauty continues in both the Leaden and the Golden Echoes. Thus, the question of faith reveals itself throughout this restless syntax of Hopkins’ “The Leaden Echo and the Golden Echo” with the sudden interruptions of lines, and repetitions in relation with the subconcious.

Firstly, the sudden enjambments throughout the poem generate a semantic discomfort, contradicting the grace of God suggested by “the Golden Echo.” For example, metaphors in the poem are abruptly interrupted by the coming lines. “Ó is there no frowning of these wrinkles, rankèd wrinkles deep, / Dówn? no waving off of these most mournful messengers, still”[3] and again a sudden interruption and transition: “Messengers, sad and stealing messengers of grey?”[4] We see wrinkles, a "messenger" of old age, expressed through a sudden enjambment; thus the metaphor is interrupted suddenly in the voice of the Leaden Echo. The interruption of this metaphor resembles the interruption of life. The metaphor, coming with such an interruption remind of us that life and voice could be cut off suddenly by death. This also generates the feeling of not being able to complete one's words. This makes the syntax of poem far from the relief that belief provides. Not only the hopeless Leaden Echo, but also the graceful Golden Echo speaks with the interruptions of lines. The restless interruptions of lines appear in the syntax of the Golden Echo. Even when it seems to provide promising answers in the name of God’s eternity and grace for the Leaden Echo’s complaints regarding the transience of beauty. For instance, only before “giving beauty back to God”[5] in order to transcend the temporality of beauty, the Golden Echo says: “To its own best being and its loveliness of youth: it is an ever- / lastingness of, O it is an all youth!”[6] The line is suddenly interrupted and divided by the word “everlastingness.” Such an unexpected separation of “ever” indicates nothingness after the interruption, coming from death rather than the continuous notion of eternity. Thus, the sytanx of the poem constantly conveys the message of the transience of beauty and the fragility of life; even the otherwise is claimed. The religious peace that the Golden Echo seemingly offers to the fragility of beauty contrasts with the fragility of lines. Considering the psychological background of empathy, metaphors and imagination, Kendall Wallton said that “To judge that a person feels ‘like this’ is to use one’s own mental state as a sample, indicating a property that one then attributes to her.”[7] Accordingly, in the voice of echoes; the interrupted metaphors, pertaining to the transience of beauty, are built through the imagination of echoes. Yet, both their imagination of beauty and eternity is merged with the interrupted lines in the syntax as if the Leaden Echo and the Golden Echo are speaking from the “one” mental state with the same self-consciousness. The interruption of lines and metaphors generate a shared feeling of inadequacy and a similar feeling of incompleteness. Hence, this creates a discourse in the poem which reveals the dilemma of faith and doubt with the sharp enjambments, contradicting the graceful experience of faith.

On the other hand, the word repetitions, seen in “The Leaden Echo and The Golden Echo” reflect an internal conflict, rather than the peaceful relief of faith. In other words, the inner discomfort of the subconscious reveals itself through such repetitions. Repetitions can be thought of as a way of struggling with death and transience, and they also hide the failure of this struggle within themselves. For example, the repetition of the word beauty comes at first: “…back beauty, keep it, beauty, beauty, beauty,... from vanishing / away.”[8] By chanting the word “beauty” over and over again, the Leaden Echo seems to be trying to hold and capture beauty. In this way, it tries to prevent beauty from passing away with a repetitive suspension. Yet, the repetition of despair intervenes: “Be beginning to despair, / Despair, despair, despair, despair.”[9] Here, it can be seen that beauty cannot surpass death, since this time it is the despair brought by death that repeats itself. From Sigmund Freud’s perspective, repetitions could be a sign of repressions of the subconscious, relating to the death drive.[10] The repetitive words of “echoes” are far from overcoming the fragility of life and transience. In fact, they seem to be a sign of the repression of the harsh reality of fragile beauty, confronted with destruction. In addition to the repetition of words in the voice of the discouraged Leaden Echo, these repetitions still exist in the voice of the Golden Echo even though it claims the grace of God’s eternity over the destruction of death. For instance, the Golden Echo says: “See; not a hair is, not an eyelash, not the least lash lost; every hair / Is, hair of the head, numbered.”[11] The repetition of the word “hair” implies the repetitive cycle of losing hair until death, as every hair falls out with the aging process. In this context, the repetition of the word hair can be interpreted as the effort for more strands of hair that do not fall out and thus eternal youth. Yet, the repetitions are not enough to hold youth and beauty. Hair strands are “numbered” as seconds are numbered in our lives, and they can suddenly disappear completely. Furthermore, with a repetitive cycle again, the Golden Echo expresses that what is being followed is there: “Yonder, yes yonder, yonder, / Yonder.”[12] These repetitions generate a chaotic atmosphere rather than the sense of tranquility that belief and Heaven are supposed to bring. The Golden Echo actually appears to defend faith and eternity of God; nonetheless, the repetitions in the syntax emphasize doubt. Moreover, the word “yonder” itself brings uncertainty and doubt; the place remains ambigous and implies an inadequacy of our limited knowledge. The words, repeating themselves throughout the poem seem to be an attempt to believe, and to be on the safe side of belief against death. However, this vague repetition at the end of the poem also show that there is no graceful peace in the end either at the subconscious level. Both the restless syntax of echoes, filled with the repetitions, thus raises the question of faith, even when the Golden Echo seems to argue the otherwise.

In conclusion, the sharp enjambments and word repetitions in the syntax of Gerard Manley Hopkins’ “The Leaden Echo and the Golden Echo” reveal the dilemma of faith and doubt. The Golden Echo’s desire to be eternal in the name of God’s beauty becomes invalid, since the contradictory discourse generated by the restless syntax comes to the play, and the dialogue of echoes in the poem brings a monophonic structure. The discourses of echoes with the distressed enjambments and word repetitions become compatible with each other. Hence, the both imply the question of faith at the subconscious level, and the darkness, arising from the unavoidable question. Further examinations of Hopkins’ poetic discourse might provide new insights into the relationship between language and the subconscious.

References

Bakhtin, Mikhail. Problems of Dostoevsky’s Poetics. Edited and translated by Caryl Emerson. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 1984.

Freud, Sigmund. Beyond The Pleasure Principle. Translated by James Strachey. London: The Hogarth Press and The Institute Of Psychoanalysis, 1955.

Hopkins, Gerard Manley. Poems and Prose of Gerard Manley Hopkins. New York: Penguin Books, 1985.

Walton, Kendall L. In Other Shoes: Music, Metaphor, Empathy, Existence. NY: Oxford University Press, 2015.

 

 


[1] Gerard Manley Hopkins, Poems and Prose of Gerard Manley Hopkins (New York: Penguin Books, 1985), 52-54.

[2] Mikhail Bakhtin, Problems of Dostoevsky’s Poetics, ed. and trans. by Caryl Emerson (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 1984), 249, 250.

[3] Hopkins, 52.

[4] Ibid, 54.

[5] Hopkins, 54.

[6] Ibid, 53.

[7] Kendall L. Walton, In Other Shoes: Music, Metaphor, Empathy, Existence (NY: Oxford University Press, 2015), 6.

[8] Hopkins, 52.

[9] Ibid, 53.

[10] Sigmund Freud, Beyond The Pleasure Principle, trans. by James Strachey (London: The Hogarth Press and The Institute Of Psychoanalysis, 1955), 44.

[11] Hopkins, 54.

[12] Ibid, 54.

 
 
 

Comments


Post: Blog2_Post
  • Twitter
  • Instagram

©2020 by Çekirdek Kabuğu. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page