An Introduction To American Transcendentalism
American Transcendentalism remains important in the history of literature. Ralph Waldo
Emerson and Henry Thoreau are prominent poets of this movement and they brought many innovations to the world of ideas. In Emerson’s The Poet and Thoreau’s The Conclusion have similar themes to each other with slight differences, and shed light on optimism, minimalism and deep-rooted social judgments in those texts.
First of all, the theme of optimism stands out in Emerson’s The Poet and Thoreau’s The Conclusion. Transcendentalist authors are known to have an optimistic view of life; they are far from melancholia and pessimism. This property can also be seen in Emerson's The Poet. Emerson points out the importance of seeing the big picture and says: "Readers of poetry see the factory-village, and the railway, and fancy that the poetry of the landscape is broken up by these. For these works of art are not yet consecrated in their reading; but the poet seem the fall withing the great Order not less than the bee-hive, or the spiders geometrical web." Here, when Emerson mentions “the readers of poetry,” I think of people who constantly complain all the times and tend to find ugliness in everything. Sometimes we all have this tendency. When Emerson mentions “the poet”, it reminds me of wise people who can see the big picture and realize the truth of the events. For example, ”the readers of poetry” would curse their fate and complain in the situation of failure while the poet would see the failure as a part of the order. Therefore, the poet would see a wisdom and a good side in this failure, trusting Order and the Creator. An unfavorable event, like experiencing failure, was necessary as the presence of the bee-hive. It can be seen that Emerson does not support melancholy and pessimism, on the contrary, he attributes such feelings to little knowledge. Also, there appears to be a reference to the concepts of Sufism: “külli” reason that understands the world and the “cüz’i” reason that understands the meaning of things and events in the world to the extent that God allows us. Similarly, Thoreau prefers a positive outlook on life and stresses that complaining is not a nice attitude: "The fault-finder will find faults even in paradise." and "Some would find fault with the morning red, if they ever got up early enough." It can be seen that Thoreau attributes a value to the individual when he calls the fault “finder.” For example, imagine that you are poor, you can spend your life complaining about it, or take advantage of what this poverty brings to you: for example, you will not have heirs waiting for you to die, or there will be no people hanging out with you for your money; perhaps you will have more satisfying relationships. Here, Thoreau combines optimism with individuality. It depends on you, how you perceive it. Moreover, Thoreau says: "However mean your life is, meet it and live it, do not shun it and call it hard names." It can be seen that Thoreau obviously does not say run away from life or curse it; nonetheless, says meet your life. Thus, it reveals that Emerson and Thoreau both talk about life from an optimistic point of view.
The idea of minimalism emerges out of Emerson’s The Poet and Thoreau’s The
Conclusion. In The Conclusion, Henry Thoreau says: "Do not trouble yourself much to get
new things, whether clothes or friends. Turn the old; return to them." This means that we can use the old and we can try to be satisfied with what we have instead of constantly getting and consuming something new. It is important that a writer, especially a writer who came out of America's consumption culture, focuses on minimalism many years ago. Furthermore, Thoreau does not limit minimalism to things, but he also expands to people. In addition, Throeau also says: "Money is not required to buy one necessary of the soul." In other words, the idea that money is a necessity for the soul is an illusion. There is a common belief that you will be happy if you have a good house, an expensive car, cool parties. You can be happy without having a nice house and a car, or your soul may feel unhappy and restless even if you have a nice house and a car. It is a kind of destruction of the American Dream that what the popular culture imposes us; yet, Thoreau saw that the need for the soul was not a new home and a new person. Actually, if we go a little further, the resources to satisfy the needs of the soul are not in the outside, but in the inside of us. For Transcendentalists, the need of soul can also be found in the nature or the interaction with the Over Soul. Similarly, it can be said that Emerson has a minimalist perspective, perfectly suited to the Transcendentalist Club: "We fill the hands and nurseries of our children with all manner of dolls, drums, and horses, withdrawing their eyes from the plain face and sufficing objects of nature, the sun, and the moon, the animals, the water, and the stones, which should be their toys." Instead of filling our children's rooms with toys, we should take them to the nature. Many families buy new toys for their children every day, sometimes they cannot find a place to put them. In Emerson's point of view, all these ordinary toys are unnecessary. There is no point in buying such objects for our children while nature stands outside. Moreover, Emerson also emphasizes greed: "If thou fill thy brain with Boston and New York, with fashion and covetousness..." and continues: "...thou shalt find no radiance of wisdom in the lonely waste of the pinewoods." Similar to Thoreau, Emerson points out that satisfaction can attract and bring wisdom, not the covetousness. Greed constantly pushes us to dissatisfaction. Although we have the best car, we will be unhappy if we do not have the next model. Therefore, Transcendentalist authors such as, Emerson and Thoreau criticize greedy and unnecessary abundance in their prominent texts.
Transcendentalist authors lead us to question the general and ingrained judgments in society. In The Conclusion, Thoreau says: “The surface of the earth is soft and impressible by the feet of men; and so with the paths which the mind travels. How worn and dusty, then must be the highways of the world, how deep ruts of tradition and conformity.” It is noteworthy that Thoreau used the adjectives “worn” and “dusty” because this actually reflects his view of ingrained, traditional opinions of society. When we read this sentence, we feel as if the old rules should change and new ones should be replaced, in this respect it can even be called a revolutionary idea. Unlike Thoreau, in The Poet, Emerson says: "Every truth is also a prison." In other words, if we change the old ones this time, the new ones can become a prison for us. In Emerson's point of view it is always important to question our values and not to approach them in a dogmatic way. Hence, it can be seen that Emerson's The Poet and Thoreau's The Conclusion question values of society. Moreover, both Thoreau and Emerson draw attention to people who are not understood in society. As it is known, many great writers, painters and scientists had not seen any value in the society for years. Those talented people are often valued or understood in society after their deaths. In The Conclusion, Thoreau says: "Sometimes we are inclined to class those who are once-and-a-half-witted with the half-witted because we appreciate only a third part of their wit.” Thoreau emphasizes that we can only appreciate as much as we can understand, so our judgments may be wrong. This can be explained by the fact that geniuses in society do not see the value they deserve. We understand that if the society is not at a level that can understand genius, we cannot determine the value of genius by following the value judgment in society. In The Poet Emerson presents this idea in a different way, using the metaphor of the priest and the child: “Certain priests whom he describes as conversing very learnedly together, appeared to the children, who were at some distance, like dead horses: and many the like misappearances.” It seems that the wise priests will not make sense for an immature child, likewise talented people for many societies do not mean anything. This reminds me of a saying of Mevlana Jalaluddin Rumi: "No matter how much you know, you can only explain as much as the listener can understand." Hence, in Emerson’s The Poet and Thoreau’s The Conclusion actually provide an explanation for the situation of genius people, experiencing the lack of value in society.
To conclude with, the themes of optimism, minimalism and the society’s rooted judgments can be found in Emerson’s The Poet and Thoreau’s The Conclusion. The Transcendentalist movement has brought much to American literature and the lives of its readers. Transcendentalist authors do not seem to lose their influence, as the tendency for returning to nature increases in the 21st century.





Comments